The Historical Muhammad

Question from Jannatul:


surely u can deny God(ALLAH) but how will u deny the very existence of His prophet muhammad who lived in this earth and His revelations, all the predictions are coming true, what do u think about them…….Have u studied the Quran and pondered over Islam, if not I advice u to do it right away

Answer by SmartLX:

There’s a Wikipedia article on the historicity of Muhammad which says that ” the historicity of Muhammad, aside from his existence, is debated. ” There is enough evidence of the existence of the man Muhammad that the fact that he existed is generally not debated. All the debate concerning him is focused on two things, as far as I can gather: the truth of the supernatural claims surrounding him (i.e. his interactions with Allah) and the morality of his actions (e.g. ordering the deaths of unbelievers, or marrying and bedding a girl of nine or ten).

As for his prophecies, here are my thoughts on prophecies in general, and here is an article on the exposure of supposed prophecies in the Quran as far from prophetic.

4 thoughts on “The Historical Muhammad”

  2. MUHAMMAD is an example of a SEA LION, from my answer to Smartlx on another question, with which he had answered me, only, he, M, dared not have 60, but ‘only’ 6 females in his harem.
    This is not that he did not want to, but because his MALE BODY SIZE, COMPARED TO BODY SIZES OF FEMALES, was not 500 kilos to 50, but ‘only’ 100 to 50. Poor bastard.
    As for his ‘GODLY’ attributes, as a human, it is under me to discuss SUCH.
    I leave it to Smartlx, because it is his duty to discuss the dirt of theists’ minds

    1. In case my answer above about M is not factual, I apologize to all Muslims who have him as not just a dirty male but as a godly dirty male, while other sultans and such males in ISLAM, prove me right, even righter, because their harems were much larger than of any of sea lions of 500 kilos body size. Sea lions cannot do what sultans in Islam did and perhaps still do somewhere on Earth, because there are other male sea lions to prevent one from having all the beautiful young women of their country at their penises’ disposal, being able so because we humans have MONEY AND ARMS, while poor sea lions have only their body strength to keep for themselves 60 females, their children then being semi brothers and sisters, a bad idea, while the ‘lesser’ in body strength males…jerk it.

    2. In case my answer above about M is not factual, I apologize to all Muslims who have him as not just a dirty male but as a godly dirty male, while other sultans and such males in ISLAM, prove me right, even righter, because their harems were much larger than of any of sea lions of 500 kilos body size. Sea lions cannot do what sultans in Islam did and perhaps still do somewhere on Earth, because there are other male sea lions to prevent one from having all the beautiful young women of their country at their penises’ disposal, being able so because we humans have MONEY AND ARMS, while poor sea lions have only their body strength to keep for themselves 60 females, their children then being semi brothers and sisters, a bad idea, while the ‘lesser’ in body strength males…jerk it.
      Evolution did not have THIS in its mind, it only wanted all the females being fertilized by best sperm, but not of only a few males in the large region of population of a species.

Comments are closed.