A Pentalogy of Past Lives

Question from Jaak:
I found this interesting video on youtube, with children recalling supposed past lives. They seem genuine, do you think this demonstrates that reincarnation exists?


Answer by SmartLX:
If everything in these stories were true, it would be a choice between the reality of reincarnation (at least in a few cases) or extreme coincidences between deceased people’s lives and the imaginations of children. That “if” is a huge one, and it’s the main barrier to these stories being credible evidence for reincarnation.

The meat of each of these stories is things a child has casually said to the parents, which seem unexplainable at first but then are found to match details of someone’s old life. These initial statements are never recorded, because why would parents record every word their kids say? Equally important is that the interrogation that immediately follows is never recorded, so if the parents asked leading questions that essentially fed the kid the necessary information (deliberately or not), no one can prove it. Once the parents start writing and speaking publicly about the child’s “recollections”, the child is caught in a feedback loop where repeated tellings of the story shape and reinforce the memory itself, until any fabricated parts of it seem as real as the rest. Any authors, paranormal researchers, religious figures, etc. who latch onto the story only amplify this cycle of reinforcement. Short of someone in the family admitting a total hoax, these stories never really get smaller, and not a shred of evidence is needed; only a bit of research into the life of a dead person.

Ultimately, if a kid apparently identifies as a former person then jumping to an actual reincarnation as the reason would require a pre-existing belief in reincarnation, psychologically speaking. If that’s not already there, it’s a huge shift in one’s worldview just to explain some unexplained stories that have no bearing on one’s own life. All other possibilities would have to be completely ruled out, and it’s hard to eliminate coincidence, pure or partial fabrication, and the child being led by the nose or otherwise fed details.

2 thoughts on “A Pentalogy of Past Lives”

  1. A good question, by a RELIGIOUS person, asking themselves, would be HOW COME these things, like ‘MIRACLES’ and other such ‘SUPERNATURAL’ events never happen to ATHEISTS.

    Never, ever.

    I am an atheist and have never had any such happening to me, nor have ever heard, nor read, of any such happening to other atheists.

    Never, ever.

    So, how come these things happen only to the RELIGIOUS folks, the ones that ALREADY BELIEVE of such things being possible?!

  2. I feel sad for such kids … instead of living their own lives fully they are stuck (at-least for a few impressionable years of their childhood) with the baggage of “past lives”.
    In-fact, the baggage of our current lives tends to be too much to handle for some of us!

    If re-incarnation is true (it ain’t) then memory wipe’s a great thing I’d say … I certainly don’t want to remember the sordid details of my current life!
    Yeah, yes … like Cypher in the first Matrix movie … I want my memory totally wiped 🙂 … no fragments left behind.

Leave a Reply to niki kapetanou Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *